Jury Selection Begins for Second Nuisance Case Against Smithfield

In a world where people are more connected by technology than face-to-face communication, farmers might be the last to know if a problem with their neighbors is brewing.
In a world where people are more connected by technology than face-to-face communication, farmers might be the last to know if a problem with their neighbors is brewing.
(PORK)

In a Raleigh, N.C., courtroom Tuesday, jury selection began in the second of 26 nuisance cases against Smithfield Foods, continuing a campaign to forever change hog production practices in the state.

This case, similar to the McKiver et al v. Murphy-Brown, LLC case decided on April 26, also focuses on manure management.

It centers on whether a 4,700-hog farm owned by Joey Carter, former police chief of the nearby town Beulaville, emits enough odor and sprayed liquid waste to be a nuisance to a neighboring couple. As with the previous case, the farm owner is not being sued because they are under strict contracts that detail how to raise Smithfield-owned livestock, according to attorneys for the neighbors.

Court filings by the plaintiffs say residents have dealt with odor, onslaughts of flies and pests, as well as loss of “enjoyment of their property” for years.

A Second Round Targeting Manure Handling
Arguments in the first case criticized the farm’s handling of manure, suggesting that other states have required hog farmers to use different equipment or increased regulations on storage methods. Lawyers for the defendant said discussing alternative waste-management technologies used in other states was not appropriate because soil topography, climate and lagoon construction are vastly different.

Jurors awarded the 10 plaintiffs in the first case $750,000 in compensation and $500 million in damages “designed to punish the corporation that owns the animals,” the Associated Press reported. Under North Carolina state law, punitive damage awards are capped at three times the amount of compensatory damages or $250,000, whichever is greater. This reduced the damage sentence from more than $50 million to $3.25 million to be split between the 10 plaintiffs.

Smithfield officials say a different outcome might have resulted from the first trial if the court had allowed the jury to visit the plaintiffs’ properties and the Kinlaw farm, heard evidence of odor-monitoring tests and known the history of the case itself. Smithfield plans to appeal the ruling.

As subsequent trials continue to move forward, pork producers—as well as the entire agriculture community—are cautiously watching the interaction of neighbors, consumers and farmers. In a world where people are more connected by technology than face-to-face communication, farmers might be the last to know if a problem with their neighbors is brewing.

 

 

Latest News

Shofner Uses Artificial Intelligence to Ensure Boar Semen Quality
Shofner Uses Artificial Intelligence to Ensure Boar Semen Quality

How can next-generation boar sperm analysis address the current shortcomings in sperm quality assessment? Iowa State University grad student Ian Shofner is exploring how artificial intelligence can help.

State Pork News: Don't Miss These Headlines
State Pork News: Don't Miss These Headlines

Here's a round-up of news from state pork producer organizations.

Hogs and Pigs Report: How Will Increase in Pigs Saved Per Litter Impact the Pork Outlook?
Hogs and Pigs Report: How Will Increase in Pigs Saved Per Litter Impact the Pork Outlook?

Of all the numbers in the latest USDA Hogs and Pigs Report, the number that caught economists’ eye was pigs saved per litter. Here's why Steve Meyer, Ever. Ag senior economists, says this is a number to watch.

Why You Need to Understand How USDA Purchase Programs Work
Why You Need to Understand How USDA Purchase Programs Work

With pork producers facing prolonged economic headwinds, recent USDA commodity purchases of pork offer relief at pivotal times. It’s important to understand how these programs work, says NPPC president Lori Stevermer.

Get the Facts Straight on Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza
Get the Facts Straight on Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza

Now that the mystery illness impacting some dairy herds has been revealed as the same strain of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza that has been impacting the U.S. poultry flock, pork producers are asking questions.

Merck Introduces Sequivity with Microsol Diluvac Forte Adjuvant Prescription Vaccine
Merck Introduces Sequivity with Microsol Diluvac Forte Adjuvant Prescription Vaccine

Merck Animal Health announced it has received license approval from the USDA for Sequivity with Microsol Diluvac Forte adjuvant prescription vaccine for use in gilts and sows.